Buyers of life contingent structured settlement payment rights face exposure to mortality risk that can be mitigated with life insurance. One of our readers raises some interesting questions about mortality exposure which I will attempt to answer in this informative post.
She writes "Apparently folks like myself who buy life contingent payment rights also receive a life insurance policy on the original annuitant to protect their investment in addition to the policy for rights to those payments.If the original annuitant dies before payments are due to start, then the buyer receives the life insurance proceeds instead of the life contingent payments.
If the original annuitant commits suicide within the first year (what I've been told), the entire investment is lost (no life insurance and no life contingent payments)."
Her questions...
Question: Is suicide a concern for losing the investment only within the first year after payment rights transfer?
Comment:
The suicide clause in a life insurance contract is designed to prevent people who are contemplating taking their own lives from obtaining life insurance. It is considered to be contrary to public interest to encourage suicide by making insurance proceeds available to those who see no way out of their financial difficulties
To accomplish this, the life insurance suicide clause states that if the insured commits suicide within a specified period of time, the policy will automatically be voided. Generally the length of time is 1 to 2 years and the contract provision applies whether regardless of the sanity of the insured at the time of the act.
Once the suicide exclusion period of time has elapsed, the insurance company must pay the claim even if the insured commits suicide. However, if suicide occurs while the time limit is still in effect, the company will usually only refund any premiums that the policy-owner has paid for the coverage. Accrued interest on the premiums typically won't be refunded, as the company will use it to offset part of its costs in initially setting up the policy.
Questions: A. How does one keep track of the living status of the original annuitant for the next couple decades if payments aren't scheduled to start for least 20 years? B. How does one learn if the original annuitant died even if they own a life insurance policy on that annuitant?
Most of the life insurers issuing structured settlements use an electronic version of the "Social Security Death Master" database (neither Darth Vader, nor the Key Master of Gozer are involved) to cross reference against their policy records. A more basic version of the Social Security death records can be found here
The reader's question is very timely because there have recently been allegations that life insurers aren't doing enough to find and pay beneficiaries after an insured dies. At issue is an accusation that life insurers are using the Social Security Administration's Death Master File — an account of all Americans who die — to stop annuity payments, but not to track down and pay beneficiaries of life insurance policies. A task force of industry regulators is working with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners ("NAIC") to draft a Model law and procedures. It will then be up to each state to decide if additional regulations are necessary.
Question: if the original annuitant dies (not of suicide during the first year) would the proceeds of the entire life insurance policy be tax-free to the owner/beneficiary?
A. As stated in IRC 101(a)(1) General rule
"Except as otherwise provided in paragraph (2), subsection (d), subsection (f), and subsection (j), gross income does not include amounts received (whether in a single sum or otherwise) under a life insurance contract, if such amounts are paid by reason of the death of the insured."
B. HOWEVER, another issue may or may not come into play, so pay close attention...
IRC 101(a)(2) Transfer for valuable consideration
"In the case of a transfer for a valuable consideration, by assignment or otherwise, of a life insurance contract or any interest therein, the amount excluded from gross income by paragraph (1) shall not exceed an amount equal to the sum of the actual value of such consideration and the premiums and other amounts subsequently paid by the transferee. The preceding sentence shall not apply in the case of such a transfer—
(A) if such contract or interest therein has a basis for determining gain or loss in the hands of a transferee determined in whole or in part by reference to such basis of such contract or interest therein in the hands of the transferor, or
(B) if such transfer is to the insured, to a partner of the insured, to a partnership in which the insured is a partner, or to a corporation in which the insured is a shareholder or officer".
C. Furthermore, if there is a delay in paying death benefits generally life insurers will pay interest from the date of death tio the date of settlement of the life insurance claim. The interest is taxable.
Question: What if the life insurance company insuring the annuitant goes under - can I just get another life insurance policy for the annuitant somewhere else without great effort?
That will likely depend on:
- whether or not the contract of sale of structured settlement payment rights covers this contingency;
- whether the "measuring life" can be located;
- whether the "measuring life" is still insurable.
Question: Why is life insurance on the original annuitant even needed?
Even if the state court process changes the direct ownership of structured settlement payment rights to the buyer, without life insurance on the "original annuitant", the purchaser of life contingent structured settlement payment rights, with no periodic certain would bear the full mortality risk and could lose everything.
About the author: John Darer sells a wide variety of life insurance products as solutions to help mitigate financial risk exposures of individuals, families and businesses. As a Chartered Life Underwriter and Chartered Financial Consultant with over 28 years in the life insurance business, he has an extensive body of knowledge and concomitant network of contacts to place, or attempt to place your toughest cases.
Other Resources:
Life Insurance in the settlement planning process